Best Fixed Indexed Annuity Companies

Most people shopping for a fixed indexed annuity focus on the wrong thing first — they chase the highest cap rate they can find, then pick a carrier. That's backwards. The carrier's financial strength, how they've maintained cap rates over time, and whether their rider structure actually fits your income timeline matters more than whatever number is on the illustration today. I've placed enough of these to know that a carrier who quietly cuts caps after year two costs clients far more than a slightly lower starting rate from a company that holds the line.

The five companies below represent the carriers I consistently recommend across our book of business — not because they have the flashiest marketing, but because they hold up under scrutiny on financials, product structure, and long-term rate maintenance. The difference shows up years later when your income rider activates and the carrier you picked on cap rate alone isn't the one holding the line.

Key Takeaways

• All five carriers on this list hold A- or better ratings from AM Best or S&P — financial strength is non-negotiable on a contract you may hold for 10 years
• Athene leads FIA sales volume with over $36 billion in total annuity sales in 2024
• Allianz charges no annual fees on most products and offers eleven distinct FIA options
• North American's NAC Guaranteed Allocation locks in rates for the entire surrender charge period — rare in this market
• Delaware Life was first to offer the Invesco QQQ ETF as a crediting index option inside an FIA
• Global Atlantic increased premium bonuses from 10% to 14% in recent product updates

What Separates the Best FIA Carriers from the Rest

Financial strength is the starting point, not the finish line. An A+ AM Best rating tells you the carrier can meet its obligations — it doesn't tell you whether they'll maintain competitive caps five years into your contract or whether their income rider math actually holds up at distribution.

The carriers that consistently rise to the top share three traits: they maintain cap rates and participation rates over time instead of leading with high numbers that quietly erode, their rider structures are transparent about costs and assumptions, and they have enough product variety that an independent agent can match the right product to the right client profile rather than forcing every situation into one chassis.

Understanding how fixed indexed annuities work and the full range of annuity types provides useful context before comparing carriers.

Best Fixed Indexed Annuity Companies Ranked

Athene leads the fixed indexed annuity market with over $36 billion in total annuity sales in 2024, making it the largest provider of fixed annuities in the United States. That sales volume matters beyond bragging rights — it signals distribution depth, carrier infrastructure, and enough premium coming in to support competitive crediting.

The flagship Agility fixed indexed annuity includes built-in income and death benefit riders at no additional cost. Most carriers charge 0.95%–1.25% annually for comparable rider packages. Getting them bundled at no explicit fee changes the long-term accumulation math meaningfully.

Athene's index lineup includes the AI Powered Global Opportunities Index (AIGO), which uses algorithmic analysis to adjust allocations based on market conditions. In favorable periods this strategy has produced index credits exceeding 20%. The tradeoff is that proprietary indexes have limited historical performance data compared to the S&P 500.

Key Athene Products

Athene AccuMax offers one, five, and seven-year terms with multiple index strategies — useful for clients who want flexibility on time horizon. Athene Ascent Pro includes an income rider with roll-up rates that compound annually for up to ten years. Performance Elite Plus adds annual liquidity riders and premium bonuses on select versions.

Athene Advantages and Disadvantages

Allianz Life posted over $12.8 billion in fixed annuity sales in 2024 and has held a top-two FIA market position for over a decade. The German parent company and global asset base provide a level of financial depth that most domestic-only carriers can't match.

The Allianz Index Advantage is one of the most widely placed FIAs in the independent channel, and for good reason — it offers multiple crediting strategies across multiple terms and charges no annual contract fees on most versions. That fee structure has a compounding effect on accumulation values over a 7–10 year surrender period.

The proprietary Index Lock feature is the product detail I point clients to most often. It allows policyholders to lock in positive index values at any point during the crediting period — before the anniversary date. In a year where the index runs up 18% in month nine and then pulls back to 11% by the anniversary, Index Lock captures the 18%. That's a structural advantage most carriers don't offer.

Allianz Product Notes

Eleven distinct FIA products give Allianz more variety than any other carrier on this list. The Benefit Control annuity addresses liquidity with enhanced access provisions compared to standard FIA contracts. Surrender periods on some products run up to ten years — longer than the industry standard of seven — which is the primary tradeoff for the fee structure and Index Lock advantages.

Allianz Advantages and Disadvantages

North American Company for Life and Health Insurance has been operating since 1886 and is a member of Sammons Financial Group — one of the largest privately held companies in the United States. That ownership structure means no quarterly earnings pressure driving short-term product decisions.

The 2026 NAC Guaranteed Allocation is the product I'd highlight first for clients who want rate certainty. It locks in guaranteed crediting rates for the entire surrender charge period — not just year one. In a market where most carriers reserve the right to adjust caps and participation rates annually, a contractually locked rate for the full term is a meaningful differentiator.

The Income Pay Pro rider embeds a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit equal to 100% of premium from day one, with a roll-up rate that compounds annually for up to ten years. For clients who want predictable income growth without market-dependent assumptions, this structure is hard to beat.

North American Product Notes

The partnership with Annexus produced the Secure Horizon suite, which addresses four retirement risks in a single product: death, impaired health, Social Security benefit volatility, and longevity. The Model Blend options inside NAC Guaranteed Allocation automatically rebalance on each contract anniversary, removing ongoing allocation decisions from the client's plate.

North American Advantages and Disadvantages

Annuities

See what 30+ A-rated carriers will pay you.

See your numbers

Delaware Life, a member of Group 1001, has placed over $20 billion in annuities since 2013 and has built its market position on index innovation rather than rate competition. The Growth Pathway FIA was the first in the industry to offer the Invesco QQQ ETF as a crediting index — giving clients exposure to technology-sector growth inside a principal-protected structure.

The Precision Portfolios within Growth Pathway are preset allocation combinations built with institutional-quality managers including Invesco, Janus Henderson, Barclays, and Franklin Templeton. For clients who want diversified index exposure without making ongoing allocation decisions, this is a cleaner structure than managing multiple index elections manually.

The 2026 Momentum Growth suite introduced a partial risk option — clients can put a portion of gains at risk for potentially higher credits than a standard FIA cap structure allows. This sits between a traditional FIA and a RILA in terms of risk profile, which opens up a different client conversation.

Delaware Life Product Notes

PrimeStart Bonus 10 combines a 10% premium bonus with crediting based on the lowest index value in the first 90 days — a dual advantage that can enhance first-year performance in volatile conditions. DualTrack Income runs two separate income tracking mechanisms simultaneously, providing flexibility on income activation timing for clients with uncertain retirement dates.

Delaware Life Advantages and Disadvantages

Global Atlantic, backed by KKR, has built its FIA identity around income flexibility — specifically the ability to customize when and how guaranteed income activates. For clients within five years of retirement who need income certainty more than accumulation upside, Global Atlantic's product suite is worth running alongside any accumulation-focused carrier.

ForeIncome II offers two distinct income options: the Guaranteed Income Builder Benefit provides consistent 10% annual growth to the withdrawal base, while the Income Multiplier Benefit credits 1.25 times any earned index credits to the income base. The ability to choose between these at the time of income activation — rather than locking in at purchase — is a structural flexibility most carriers don't offer.

Recent product updates increased premium bonuses from 10% to 14% and updated income multipliers. Those changes improve the illustration numbers meaningfully for near-retiree clients comparing options.

Global Atlantic Product Notes

ForeAccumulation II includes an optional Enhanced Death Benefit rider with a Growth Accelerator that credits higher accelerated rates while maintaining 0% minimum crediting for downside protection. Income 150+ SE adds income boosts at contract inception, annually for the first four years, and again at year ten — useful for clients with flexible retirement timelines.

Global Atlantic Advantages and Disadvantages

How to Compare Fixed Indexed Annuity Companies

The comparison framework I use with every client starts with financial strength, then moves to product fit, then to current rates — in that order.

Financial strength first: all five carriers here hold A- or better, which is the floor for a contract you may hold for a decade. Below A-, you're taking on carrier risk that no cap rate justifies.

Product fit second: income-focused clients should run Global Atlantic and North American illustrations first. Accumulation-focused clients should look at Allianz and Delaware Life. Clients who want the simplest structure with the least ongoing decision-making should start with Athene's built-in rider products.

Current rates third: current annuity rates shift monthly. What's competitive today may not be in 90 days. An independent agent running live quotes across multiple carriers gives you a real-time picture — not a snapshot from a rate sheet that's already stale.

For clients comparing annuities to other accumulation vehicles, annuities vs. CDs and annuities vs. 401k cover the tradeoffs in detail.

Most applicants comparing these carriers qualify for multiple products simultaneously — the decision comes down to which product structure fits your retirement timeline, not which carrier has the highest cap rate this month. Run your numbers across carriers before locking in.

Annuities

See what 30+ A-rated carriers will pay you.

See your numbers

FAQ