Our editorial team follows strict guidelines to ensure accuracy and objectivity. Learn more about our process.
The annuities vs CDs decision comes down to how long you can leave the money alone. For three years or more, a multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) usually pays more than the best bank CD, and the growth is tax-deferred. For a year or two, a CD is usually the better tool. Pick wrong and you either pay tax every year on interest you never touched or lock money behind a surrender charge you didn't need. We compare annuities from 30+ A-rated carriers against the best nationally available CDs. Here's how rates, taxes, and access compare this month.
Key Takeaways
Three years or longer. A MYGA usually pays more than the best bank CD, and most of that edge comes from the higher rate, not the tax break.
Two years or less. A CD usually wins: at one year the best CDs pay more than the best MYGA, at two years the rates are nearly even, and the CD has no surrender schedule.
Tax treatment. CD interest is taxed every year it's credited, even if you roll it over; MYGA growth isn't taxed until you withdraw.
Principal protection. CDs are FDIC-insured up to $250,000 per bank; MYGAs are backed by the carrier's financial strength and state guaranty associations.
Early access. Most MYGAs let you take out 10% a year without a surrender charge; CDs typically charge a penalty for any early withdrawal.
Which pays more right now?
At three years and longer, the best MYGA pays more than the best nationally available CD. At one year the CD pays more, and at two years the rates are nearly even — see top MYGA rates for the full board.
| Term | Top CD Rate | Top MYGA Rate | MYGA Advantage | MYGA Carrier |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 year | 4.89% | 4.25% | CD +0.64% | ELCO Mutual — Guardian Eagle 1 Year |
| 2 years | 5.04% | 5.15% | +0.11% | CL Life — CL Sundance 2 |
| 3 years | 5.05% | 6.10% | +1.05% | Revol One — BreakThrough 3yr / DirectGrowth 3 |
| 5 years | 5.20% | 6.40% | +1.20% | Wichita National — Security 5 |
| 7 years | 4.55% | 6.30% | +1.75% | Wichita National — Security 7 |
| 10 years | 4.65% | 6.35% | +1.70% | Oxford Life — Multi-Select 10 |
MYGA rates from carrier rate sheets verified by our licensed agents as of October 12, 2026. CD rates from RateBrain's nationwide CD lists as of October 12, 2026.
How MYGAs and CDs differ
A MYGA is a fixed annuity that works like a CD: you lock a lump sum for a set term at a guaranteed rate. A CD is a bank product with FDIC insurance up to $250,000. A MYGA is an insurance contract backed by the carrier and a state guaranty association.
| Feature | MYGA | CD |
|---|---|---|
| Tax on growth | Deferred until withdrawal | Taxed every year as earned |
| Principal protection | Carrier plus state guaranty | FDIC up to $250,000 |
| Early access | 10% free each year on most contracts | Penalty on any early withdrawal |
| At maturity | 30-day window; many products restart surrender if you miss it | Full access, no restrictions |
| Before age 59½ | 10% IRS penalty on the taxable portion | None |
| Lifetime income option | Can convert later | None |
Most MYGAs let you take 10% a year without a surrender charge. Five of the six rate leaders in the table above are rated B+ or B++ — best MYGA companies lists the rating on each term leader. Size a large deposit against your state's guaranty limit, or split it.
How much does tax deferral add?
On $200,000 for five years in the 24% federal bracket, the MYGA keeps about $12,500 more after tax — and only about $1,700 of that is the deferral. The rest is the higher rate. How annuities are taxed covers the withdrawal rules.
Expert Tip: Is a MYGA better than a CD right now?
Yes, for money you won't touch for at least three years. A 5.20% CD sounds close to a 6.40% MYGA until the CD interest gets taxed every year — on $200,000 over five years in the 24% bracket, the MYGA still finishes about $12,500 ahead after tax. Inside two years, I point clients to a CD.
—Brad Cummins, Insurance Geek Founder
When a CD wins
A CD wins when you need the money inside two years, on a fixed date, or you just want a bank product.
- Two years or less: The CD pays more at one year, matches at two, and has no surrender schedule.
- A fixed date: Closing, tuition, or a tax bill — a CD matures on that date and hands everything back.
- Under $10,000: Most competitive MYGAs start at $10,000. Use a CD or a high-yield savings account.
- You want a bank product: No carrier review, no contract language. That's a fair reason to stay in a CD.
If you can leave the money alone for three years or more, take the MYGA. If the cash is sitting in a 401(k) or IRA, that is annuities vs 401(k) — not this comparison.
Before you commit
Before you move a maturing CD into a MYGA, walk through the same checks we run on every case:
- Term match: Can you leave the money alone for the full guarantee, or do you need it inside two years?
- After-tax comparison: At your tax bracket, does the MYGA still beat the CD you are looking at once annual tax is in the math?
- Carrier vs FDIC: Does the AM Best rating and your state's guaranty limit fit the deposit, or does FDIC matter more to you on this money?
- Access: Will 10% a year cover any withdrawal, or do you need the whole balance on a fixed date?
- Maturity plan: Do you know whether you will withdraw, roll, or exchange before the 30-day window closes and surrender restarts?
Fill out the form below with the deposit, the term, and the CD rate you are looking at. We put the MYGA contract next to that CD — crediting rate, free withdrawal, surrender schedule, and the rating on the issuer.
Compare your numbers
We'll run the same deposit and term against this month's MYGA board so you can put the contract next to the CD you're looking at.
Conclusion
If a CD is coming due and you're looking at five more years in the bank, the first question is whether you will need that money before the term ends. Our agents see both mistakes: people lock a five-year MYGA they have to break, and people sit in a CD for five years paying tax every year on interest they never spent.
Tell us the term and the deposit. We'll show the MYGA contract next to the CD rate you're looking at — crediting rate, free withdrawal, surrender schedule, and the rating on the issuer — before you move the money.
FAQ
Annuities
You won't navigate this market better on your own.
Tell us your goal — income, growth, or guaranteed rate — and we'll narrow it to the right product and carrier.
Get My Numbers
About Brad Cummins

Brad Cummins is the founder of Insurance Geek and primary author of its educational content. Licensed since 2004, he brings over 21 years of experience structuring life insurance and IUL strategies for clients nationwide.
Fact checked by Ryan Wood

Ryan Wood is a licensed insurance professional and contributing advisor at Insurance Geek, serving as a fact checker and technical reviewer for life insurance and annuity content. First licensed in 2013, he brings more than 12 years of experience and holds licenses in over 40 U.S. states.

