Our editorial team follows strict guidelines to ensure accuracy and objectivity. Learn more about our process.
The best long term disability insurance is the policy that can issue for the monthly benefit your bills need. Brand lists that start with own-occupation specialists answer a different question. Most households do not need that file first.
Insurance Geek is an independent agency in Columbus, Ohio. We have placed disability coverage since 2004. Use our digital tools to quote, shop, and compare disability insurance across 30+ A-rated carriers, then a licensed agent finishes the file. Illinois Mutual is the model for the first quote, not the only carrier. Here is how we rank, and who each name is actually for.
Key Takeaways
Wrong test. Ranking carriers as the best own-occupation brand skips the file most people should buy.
Right test. Issue speed and whether the monthly cap fits the bills.
First quote. Simplified-issue coverage up to about $3,000 a month is the best long-term policy for most households.
Upgrade. High-limit own-occupation is best only when that cap cannot cover the paycheck.
We still shop. The names below are the usual order, not a locked list of five exclusive contracts.
How we ranked these long-term disability options
We ranked on two things: how fast a typical household file can issue, and whether the benefit cap matches the bills. We did not rank on sales volume or on who advertises the strongest own-occupation definition.
- Cap fit: If the household needs $2,400 a month, a $10,000 specialist policy is the wrong first rank.
- Issue speed: A shorter application that can place coverage beats a longer exam file the bills do not require.
- Occupation and income: High-limit names move up only when occupation class and documented income justify full underwriting.
What long-term disability insurance is, and how the definition works, lives on that page. This page is who we quote first.
| Rank | Company | Best for | Monthly benefit path |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Illinois Mutual | First issue for most households | Simplified-issue, about $200–$3,000 |
| 2 | Guardian | High-limit own-occupation upgrade | Fully underwritten, larger issue limits |
| 3 | Principal | Documented income above the SIDI cap | Fully underwritten individual DI |
| 4 | MassMutual | Licensed professionals who need more than $3,000 | Fully underwritten own-occupation |
| 5 | Ameritas | Occupation classes that need a second high-limit shop | Fully underwritten own-occupation |
Premiums and what moves them are on the disability insurance cost page.
1. Illinois Mutual
Illinois Mutual's Personal Paycheck Powered is the simplified-issue design we use as the model. Monthly benefits commonly run from about $200 to $3,000. Rates are unisex and uni-tobacco. Coverage is on or off the job. Elimination periods can start as low as 0 days accident / 7 days sickness, depending on the state.
A fast application is available on many of those cases. That is not a promise on every file. The reason this name ranks first is the cap fit. Most household bills do not need a $10,000 contract. They need a benefit that can issue.
Illinois Mutual is the example, not the only simplified-issue carrier we will shop.
2. Guardian
Guardian is the first high-limit name we look at when $3,000 a month cannot cover the paycheck. That is the physician, dentist, and other specialist file. Own-occupation language matters on that contract because the occupation cannot be swapped for a cheaper job and still pay the bills.
Guardian is not the first quote for a household whose mortgage and groceries fit inside the simplified-issue cap. It is the upgrade after that cap fails.
3. Principal
Principal is in the shop when documented income needs a larger individual contract and simplified-issue will not issue enough. The file is slower. It wants income proof and occupation class. That is the point. We do not put Principal first for a $2,000 monthly gap.
4. MassMutual
MassMutual belongs on a high-limit own-occupation shop for licensed professionals. It is a fully underwritten path. We run it when the occupation and the income both sit above the SIDI cap. We do not rank it as the best long-term disability insurance for a W-2 household with a $2,800 hole after group coverage.
5. Ameritas
Ameritas is the additional own-occupation shop when occupation class is picky and the first high-limit name is not the best offer. Same rule as the others in this half of the list: we only get here after the $3,000 simplified-issue question has been answered.
Expert Tip: Rank issue speed and cap fit
If you are shopping the best long-term disability insurance, do not start with a brand own-occupation contest. Rank the file on issue speed and whether the monthly cap fits the bills. Simplified-issue coverage is first for most households. I only move to a high-limit carrier when $3,000 a month cannot cover the paycheck.
—Brad Cummins, Insurance Geek Founder
Who should use which rank
Most households should start at rank 1. Specialists whose bills need more than $3,000 a month start the conversation at ranks 2 through 5 after we confirm the smaller cap cannot do the job.
If you already have a group plan, the second policy question is on the supplemental disability insurance page. This ranking is still the same: fill the remaining bills with the file that can issue.
Compare long-term disability options
The form starts with the benefit size that fits most households. We only open a high-limit shop when that cap is too small.
Conclusion
The best long-term disability insurance is the one that can issue at the benefit you need. For most households that is simplified-issue coverage with a cap near $3,000 a month. High-limit own-occupation brands are the right rank only after that cap fails.
Our agents see people pick a carrier because a list called it the best own-occupation name. Bring the bills. We will start with the file that can issue, and we will shop Guardian, Principal, MassMutual, or Ameritas only when $3,000 a month cannot cover them.
FAQ
Disability Insurance
We rank the file by what can issue, not by the brand name.
As an independent agency, we shop simplified-issue coverage first, then a high-limit contract only when that monthly benefit is too small.
See My Numbers
Disability Insurance
We rank the file by what can issue, not by the brand name.
As an independent agency, we shop simplified-issue coverage first, then a high-limit contract only when that monthly benefit is too small.
See My NumbersAbout Brad Cummins
Brad Cummins is the founder of Insurance Geek and primary author of its educational content. Licensed since 2004, he brings over 21 years of experience structuring life insurance and IUL strategies for clients nationwide.
Fact checked by Ryan Wood
Ryan Wood is a licensed insurance professional and contributing advisor at Insurance Geek, serving as a fact checker and technical reviewer for life insurance and annuity content. First licensed in 2013, he brings more than 12 years of experience and holds licenses in over 40 U.S. states.
